Judge blocks Trump rollback of birth control mandate nationwide

by Bamidele Ogunberu Posted on January 14th, 2019

A federal judge in Philadelphia is imposing a nationwide injunction on new Trump administration rules that allowed more employers to opt out of providing women with no-cost birth control.

U.S. District Judge Wendy Beetlestone issued the injunction Monday, stopping the government from enforcing rules scheduled to take effect imminently.

In her order, Beetlestone says states should be protected from the potential harm from the rule, which could include people losing contraceptive coverage and seeking state services.

Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro, who sued, calls the ruling a victory for the health and economic independence of women.

A federal judge in California on Sunday blocked the rules 13 states and Washington, D.C.

EARLIER: Judge blocks Trump rollback of birth control mandate in 13 states, D.C.

A federal judge on Sunday blocked the Trump administration’s roll back of Obamacare birth control mandate, protecting contraceptive coverage for residents living in 13 states and Washington, D.C.

The administration’s policy, which allows more employers to avoid providing their employees birth control coverage, was supposed to take effect on Monday.

The regulations, which the Trump administration announced in October 2017, widened the pool of employers that are allowed to claim exemption from providing contraceptive coverage to include nonprofit groups, for-profit companies, other nongovernmental employers, and schools and universities.

Previously, only explicitly religious groups could opt out if they could show “sincerely held” religious objections.

In November, the Trump administration issued final rules to enact the broader exemptions beginning Monday. Thirteen states — California, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Minnesota, New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia and Washington state, as well as Washington, D.C., sought the injunction to put the regulations on hold pending the states’ lawsuit opposing them.

U.S. District Judge Haywood Gilliam’s order — which applies only to the plaintiffs and not the rest of the country — found that there are “serious questions” about whether the new rules violate President Barack Obama’s Affordable Care Act, which stipulated that employer insurance plans must provide birth control services at no cost. Under current law, only explicitly religious organizations may opt out, as long as they could demonstrate a religious objection.

The U.S. Justice Department argued that the Affordable Care Act gave federal agencies the authority to exempt anyone they wish from the contraceptive mandate, but Gilliam found that the act provides no such authority and that the administration was claiming “unbridled discretion” to exempt “anyone they see fit.”

“The law couldn’t be clearer — employers have no business interfering in women’s healthcare decisions,” California Attorney General Xavier Becerra, who is leading the effort to overturn the rules, said in a statement.

“Today’s court ruling stops another attempt by the Trump Administration to trample on women’s access to basic reproductive care,” he said

The U.S. Justice Department argued that the rules protected only a small class of “sincere religious and moral objectors from being forced to facilitate practices that conflict with their beliefs.”

The Planned Parenthood Action Fund, the nonprofit political arm of Planned Parenthood, said Sunday: “Birth control IS health care — no matter what the Trump-Pence administration thinks or whether your boss agrees with it.”

“It is a good day when a court stops this administration from sanctioning discrimination under the guise of religion or morality,” deputy legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union Louise Melling said in a statement. “The Trump administration’s rules authorized employers and universities to strip women of birth control coverage — a benefit guaranteed to them by law, and meant to advance their health and equality. We applaud the order to enjoin the enforcement of these discriminatory rules.

Most Americans get their health insurance through their employers, and most employers voluntarily provide contraceptive coverage, government officials have said.

Obamacare’s birth control mandate requires employers to offer birth control coverage at no additional cost to their employees, and has significantly reduced people’s out-of-pocket costs for prescription drugs. One study estimates that women saved $1.4 billion on the birth control pill alone in 2013

Leave a Reply